Pin it
Blending the cozy warmth of fire-toasted marshmallows, smooth chocolate, and crisp graham crackers sends us right back to those summer nights outdoors. This frozen twist combines those familiar tastes into an impressive dessert that'll make everyone want more. What makes it special is how it comes together - a soft cookie dough wrapped around smooth vanilla ice cream, packed with all the s'mores goodies we can't get enough of.
When I brought this treat to our family cookout last year, it was gone in seconds. Kids couldn't stop staring at the cool swirls, and grown-ups were shocked I made it myself. Even my fussy nephew who hardly touches sweets came back asking for another slice.
Key Ingredients and Shopping Advice:
- Heavy cream and whole milk: You need that fat content for super smooth ice cream. Skip the low-fat stuff or you'll end up with icy chunks
- Baked flour: Pop it in the oven till it hits 165°F so it's safe to eat uncooked. This gives a tasty toasted flavor too
- Mini chocolate chips: These spread better through the dough than big ones and make rolling way easier. Go for good quality for the best melt
- Mini marshmallows: Get a new bag - check the date since older ones get hard and won't melt right
Simple Step-by-Step Guide:
- Get your cookie dough ready
- Whip your soft butter until it's fluffy for about 3 minutes. This puts air in for softness
- Mix in both sugars slowly, keep beating until it looks damp and sandy
- Add vanilla and egg just until mixed - too much mixing makes tough dough
- Stir in your baked flour mix with a spatula, stop as soon as it's all wet
- Make your ice cream base
- Stir the cream, milk and sugar until sugar's completely gone
- Put it in your cold ice cream maker bowl
- Churn it slowly - don't rush or the texture will suffer
- It's done when it looks like soft-serve and holds a gentle peak
- Set up your workspace
- Make room in your freezer first
- Put down parchment paper bigger than what you're making
- Flatten the cookie dough between two paper sheets so it won't stick
- Keep churning your ice cream until you're ready to use it
- Rolling it all together
- Move fast but carefully when you spread the ice cream
- Don't forget that 1-inch empty space around the edges to stop spillage
- Use the paper to help you, lifting it slowly to keep tension
- If dough breaks, just push it back together with your fingers
- Press gently while rolling to get rid of air bubbles
Pin it
I've learned that browning the marshmallows adds so much more flavor. My little girl always hangs around the kitchen hoping for "test bites" that don't make the final cut. When that toasty marshmallow smell fills our house, it takes us back to family camping trips and backyard fun.
Temperature Tricks That Work:
How cold or warm each part is really matters in this recipe. Your cookie dough can't be too cold or it'll crack, but it can't be too warm or it'll be sticky. Through lots of tries, I found it works best when the dough feels like play-dough in your hands.
Putting It All Together:
Making this roll is like building a good sandwich - you want the fillings spread out right. I put the graham bits down in three small batches instead of all at once. That way, every bite has some crunch. I figured this out after years of making rolled treats.
Ways To Serve It:
Let this roll be the star of your dessert table. I like to cut it ahead of time and place the slices in a circle, then pour warm chocolate sauce on top just before everyone eats. That hot-cold mix tastes amazing together.
Pin it
Keep It Fresh:
After trying lots of ways to store this dessert, I found wrapping it twice works best - first in parchment, then in plastic wrap. This keeps that freezer taste away. That extra minute of wrapping pays off when you eat it later.
In all my time baking, this frozen s'mores treat is still what people ask me to make most often. It mixes childhood flavors with a fancy look that works for any party. It does take some patience, but seeing people smile after their first bite makes it worth it. Just take your time with each step and don't worry if it's not perfect - even a messy roll tastes fantastic.
Tasty Twists To Try:
What's great about this dessert is how easy it is to change up. Try chocolate, peanut butter, or coffee ice cream instead of vanilla. Pour some caramel or hot fudge over the finished roll if you want. You can even swap the base - use chocolate chip cookie dough or brownie mix for something totally different.
Why The Swirl Works:
That pretty swirl isn't just for looks - it makes sure you get all the flavors in each bite. Work fast while the ice cream is still soft but not melted. When you press the graham bits into the ice cream before rolling, they form a barrier that stops the ice cream from making the cookie dough soggy.
Making The Most Of Marshmallows:
While the tiny marshmallows spread out nicely, big ones can make a bolder statement. If you go with larger marshmallows, try toasting them under the broiler first. Let them cool a bit before adding them to your ice cream or they'll melt it too fast. That toasty flavor really brings out the s'mores feeling.
Pin it
Feeding A Crowd:
Need more? Just double or triple everything and use bigger parchment paper. If you're making several rolls, you can mix up the dough and ice cream ahead of time and keep them separate in the fridge until you're ready to put them together. This saves you stress when you've got company coming.
Make It Look Amazing:
How this dessert looks matters almost as much as how it tastes. Cut even slices and arrange them in a spiral on your plate. Drizzle with warm chocolate or caramel, then sprinkle extra graham bits or toasted marshmallows on top. Add berries or mint for color. You want it to look as good as it tastes.
From what I've seen, this frozen s'mores roll isn't just dessert - it's a whole experience. It takes you back to summer nights and stories around the fire. It brings people together and creates memories. Whether you're making it for a birthday or just because it's Tuesday, give it a try. You might find your new favorite treat.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use store ice cream?
- Totally! While homemade adds a smoother touch, a quality store-bought version works just as well.
- → How much freezing time is needed?
- Give it at least 4 hours, but overnight is best for the ideal texture.
- → Can I prep it ahead?
- Yes! You can make this up to a week beforehand if stored tightly wrapped in the freezer.
- → Why use tiny chocolate chips?
- Smaller chips mix better and add even chocolatey bits to every bite.
- → Is it okay to toast the marshmallows?
- Go ahead! Giving them a gentle toast adds that classic s'mores taste—just cool them before mixing.