Mini Jar Cheesecakes

These bite-sized sweetened condensed milk cheesecakes offer a smooth blend of creaminess in handy, personal portions. The mix of velvety, lush filling on top of a buttery graham base makes a tempting sweet treat that feels fancy but tastes like home comfort. They're uniquely silky thanks to sweetened condensed milk taking the place of regular sugar, setting them worlds apart from run-of-the-mill cheesecakes. I whipped these up for my kid's graduation bash just last week. Everyone loved getting their own little dessert, and I had to give out the recipe to quite a few folks. What makes them so good? That sweetened condensed milk works magic - it gives them a smoothness you just can't get with plain sugar.

Key Ingredients

• Cream Cheese: Go for the real deal - full-fat and let it sit out till it's soft. I've found out the hard way that cold cream cheese makes lumps, and the light stuff just doesn't cut it texture-wise
• Sweetened Condensed Milk: This stuff is pure gold - it adds sweetness and creaminess all at once. Stick with full-fat for the best results
• Graham Crackers: Get the fresh, crunchy ones for your base. I like using honey grahams because they add a nice sweet touch
• Eggs: They need to be room temp so they mix in smoothly. Cold eggs can mess up your batter
• Extracts: Vanilla and lemon together make the flavor pop. Real extracts really do taste better than the fake stuff

I've been making cheesecakes for ages now, and I've learned one big thing - ingredients at room temp are a game-changer. They blend way better and that's how you get that dreamy, smooth texture we all want.

Simple Cooking Instructions

1. Making Your Base

• Smash graham crackers until they're all fine crumbs
• Stir in melted butter until it looks like damp sand
• Put one tablespoon in each jar so they're all the same
• Press down lightly with a spoon, but don't pack it too tight

2. Mixing Your Filling

• Beat the cream cheese by itself until it's totally smooth, for about 3 minutes
• Clean your bowl and beaters between adding new stuff
• Add the sweetened condensed milk gradually while you mix
• Put in eggs one by one, mixing just enough to combine
• Stir in extracts carefully to keep everything smooth

3. Whipping Up The Sauce

• Clean strawberries and cut the bigger ones in half
• Mix them with sugar, cornstarch, water, and a squeeze of lemon in a pot
• Warm it up slowly and keep stirring so it doesn't clump
• Smoosh the berries a bit as they cook for natural texture
• Let it bubble until the sauce gets thick enough to coat a spoon, around 5-8 minutes

4. Putting It All Together

• Scoop the same amount into each jar
• Don't fill them up completely - leave room for sauce and extras
• Tap each jar to get rid of air bubbles
• Wipe the rims with a wet paper towel before they go in the oven

5. Cooking Them Right

• Set jars on a baking sheet with edges
• Add hot water to the pan, about halfway up the jars
• Bake at 300°F - getting this temperature right really matters
• They're done when the middle still wiggles a bit

Pin it

My grandma always told me to tap each jar before baking to get the air bubbles out. She'd say patience was what made cheesecakes turn out right. After making these tons of times, I gotta say she was spot on.

Pin it

Mastering Cheesecake Skills

Getting that perfect texture means knowing how your ingredients work together. The sweetened condensed milk isn't just for sweetness - it helps with structure too. And being careful with your mixing is how you get that super smooth result.

Keeping and Eating

You can keep these little cheesecakes in the fridge for about five days and they'll still taste great. They're so handy for parties since everyone can just grab their own without any fuss.

Pin it

Warm Ingredients Work Best

Don't skip letting your ingredients warm up to room temp. It's not just a suggestion. I learned this when I rushed once and used cold cream cheese. The whole batch had tiny lumps all through it.

Pro Cooking Advice

• Check if they're done by giving the pan a little shake - centers should still move slightly
• Let them cool all the way before putting toppings on or you'll get water droplets
• Don't tighten the lids all the way when storing or they'll get too moist

I've tweaked this recipe for years, and I've found these mini treats bring just as much joy as a big cheesecake but they're way easier to handle and serve. The single servings make them great for sharing, and you can top them with all sorts of things. They're fancy enough for special days but simple enough for a weeknight sweet tooth fix.

Pin it

Wrapping Up

These tiny sweetened condensed milk cheesecakes show what's great about homemade desserts - they're easy but still fancy, classic but with a fresh twist, and they're just plain fun to share. After making batch after batch in my kitchen, I've found their charm isn't just in how creamy they are or how perfect the size is, but in how they bring folks together around the table. Each little jar is like a tiny labor of love. What started as me trying to solve the problem of serving cheesecake at parties has turned into one of my favorite go-to recipes. The rich, smooth filling with the crunchy graham base, topped with bright strawberry sauce, makes a dessert that feels both old-school and new at the same time. The recipe isn't rocket science, but it's the small things - room temp ingredients, gentle mixing, getting the oven temp just right - that turn these mini cheesecakes from pretty good to absolutely amazing.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can these be made early?

Definitely! Make them two days ahead. Just wait until serving to add the topping.

→ What jars work best?

4-ounce mason jars are a great size for single servings.

→ Why mix eggs on low speed?

It keeps air bubbles minimal and helps avoid cracks.

→ Can I switch the toppings?

Absolutely. Try caramel or any fruit topping you like.

→ How long do they last?

Keep them in the fridge for up to five days. You can freeze them (no sauce) for three months.