Creamy Frozen Cottage Cheese

This silky cottage cheese frozen dessert turns an ordinary breakfast item into an extravagant cold treat with way less guilt than standard ice cream. Loaded with protein and needing just 5 basic ingredients, it's become my go-to trick for wowing friends with something that's both tasty and good for you.

I stumbled on this method during a hot spell when I craved something cold but only had cottage cheese in my refrigerator. The outcome was so unexpectedly yummy that it's now what I always make for summer family get-togethers where everyone tries to guess what makes it so special.

What You'll Need

• 2 cups cottage cheese: Whole milk type gives the richest feel but reduced fat works if you want something lighter
• 1/2 cup heavy cream: Adds necessary fat for smooth freezing though you can swap in milk for fewer calories
• 1/4 cup honey: Adds sweetness that works well with the tang try getting some from nearby beekeepers for better taste
• 1 tsp vanilla extract: Makes everything sweeter without extra sugar real stuff tastes way better than imitation
• Pinch of salt: Brings out all other tastes and cuts the sweetness down a bit regular sea salt does the job nicely

How To Make It

Mix Everything Smooth:

Put all stuff in a good blender and run it until completely smooth which takes about 2 3 minutes. You want it silky with no little cottage cheese bits left. Stop and push down what sticks to the sides so everything gets mixed in. When done, it should stick to the back of a spoon.

Cool It Down:

Put in a bowl and cover with plastic wrap that touches the top so no skin forms. Stick in the fridge at least 2 hours so flavors mix together and it freezes better later. Cold mix before freezing means smaller ice bits and smoother results.

Use A Machine If You Have One:

Pour your cold stuff into an ice cream maker and let it work according to what the manual says usually around 20 25 minutes. Look for it getting thick and growing about 30% bigger. It's ready when it looks like soft serve that holds shape but still moves a little when you scoop it.

No Machine? No Problem:

Pour everything into a wide flat container so it freezes faster and more evenly. Put in freezer and check every 30 minutes. Each time, stir hard with a fork breaking up ice chunks. Do this 4 5 times over 2 3 hours until it gets too stiff to mix easily.

Finish Freezing:

Move to a sealed container with not much air space to stop freezer burn. Put wax paper right on top before closing for extra protection. Freeze another 2 3 hours until firm enough to scoop but still smooth.

Time To Eat:

Let it sit out 5 10 minutes before scooping so it's not too hard. Use cold bowls so it doesn't melt too fast and top with fresh fruit crunchy cereal or a little more honey for contrast.

Pin it

What I love most about making this is seeing how shocked people are when they try it. My sister who usually stays away from milky desserts actually asked me for the directions after having some at our last cookout saying it was the smoothest ice cream she'd ever had.

Different Tastes To Try

The main recipe works great as a starting point for tons of flavor options. If you love chocolate, throw in 3 tablespoons of cocoa powder while blending. Coffee fans will dig 1 tablespoon of instant espresso mixed into the cream beforehand. I personally love adding 1 cup of fresh strawberries or blueberries which gives amazing color and bright flavors that work well with the slight tang from the cottage cheese.

Make Ahead and Storage

This frozen treat stays good in the freezer for about two weeks when packed right. The extra protein from cottage cheese actually helps keep it from getting too hard like many homemade frozen desserts do. Keep it in a flat airtight container with wax paper pressed on top before putting the lid on. When you want some, let it sit out for around 10 minutes so you can scoop it easily.

Health Perks

Unlike normal ice cream, this cottage cheese version comes with some real health upsides. Each serving has about 12 grams of protein which slows down how your body absorbs sugar and keeps you feeling full longer. It's got lots of calcium for strong bones and some types of cottage cheese even add good gut bacteria. If you're watching your sugar, you can use stevia or monk fruit instead of honey without messing up the texture too much.

Pin it

This simple, velvety frozen treat will surprise your friends and definitely become your new warm-weather favorite!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Is low-fat cottage cheese a good substitute?

Sure, you can swap in low-fat cottage cheese, but it might not be as creamy as the full-fat version.

→ What’s a good substitute for honey or maple syrup?

Agave syrup, sugar, or any sweetener you like works; just tweak the amount to your preference.

→ Do I have to own an ice cream maker?

Nope! Freeze the mix in a container and stir it every half hour to keep the texture smooth.

→ How can this dessert be made dairy-free?

Swap for almond or coconut-based cottage cheese, and instead of heavy cream, use coconut cream.

→ What toppings work well with this dessert?

Try it with fresh berries, nuts, granola, chocolate chips, caramel, or a bit of chocolate sauce.