Pin it
Mouthwatering Patty Melts on Rye With My Bacon Magic Sauce
The whole family asks for these patty melts every single weekend. There's something about the mix of butter-grilled rye, tender beef patties and two different gooey cheeses that just hits the spot. But honestly, what makes everyone go crazy is my bacon-packed secret sauce. You'll get why these vanish so quickly in our home after just one taste.
What's So Special About These
I found out that mixing sharp cheddar with smooth provolone gives you that amazing stretch when you take a bite. The sauce came to be when I had some bacon left from breakfast one day and now my kids refuse these without it. That rye bread gets so wonderfully crunchy and doesn't fall apart with all the yummy fillings. The beef patties stay super moist thanks to good seasoning and I make them just a bit bigger than the bread slices.
Grab These Items
- Ground Beef: Go for 80/20 fat content for the juiciest results.
- Rye Bread: Get it fresh from a local bakery instead of the supermarket stuff.
- Two Cheeses: Grab some sharp cheddar and aged provolone for the ultimate melty goodness.
- Real Butter: Pick unsalted so you can control how golden your sandwiches get.
- Sauce Ingredients: Good mayo, crunchy bacon pieces, ketchup, a tiny bit of sugar and sweet pickle relish.
Simple Cooking Instructions
- Shape Your Patties
- Form your ground beef into squares that match your bread size. Push your thumb into the center of each one to stop them from bulging when they cook. Add plenty of salt and pepper on both sides then put them aside while you heat your pan.
- Get Those Patties Going
- Make sure your skillet is really hot before adding the meat. Cook them about 4 minutes per side for medium. Wait for that nice brown crust before you flip them. When they're done, let them rest while you work on the sauce.
- Whip Up That Tasty Sauce
- Fry your bacon till it's super crispy and chop it into tiny bits. Stir it together with mayo, ketchup, a little sugar and sweet relish. Check the flavor and tweak it if needed. Let it sit for a bit so all those tastes can blend while you put your sandwiches together.
- Build Your Sandwiches
- Spread butter all over each bread slice, right to the edges. Put cheddar on one slice, add your patty, slather on plenty of bacon sauce, then layer on provolone. Top with the other bread slice and press down lightly so it stays together.
- Toast Them Up
- Put your sandwich in a pan on medium heat. Let it cook for 3-4 minutes on each side until you see that nice golden color. For the last minute, put a lid on the pan so the cheese gets completely melty without burning the bread.
- Ready to Enjoy
- When both sides are nice and crispy and your cheese is all gooey, move it to a cutting board. Wait just a minute before cutting so all that melted cheese doesn't run out everywhere.
Tricks I've Learned
Give your bread a quick toast first and you'll get better crispiness. Use plenty of butter for that amazing crust. Stick with medium heat or you'll end up with burnt outsides and cold middles. Try adding hot sauce to the bacon mix if you want some kick or throw in some smoked paprika for extra flavor.
Pin it
Answers To Your Questions
If you can't get good rye bread, sourdough works great too. You can use turkey bacon in the sauce if you prefer, or leave it out and add a bit of smoked salt instead. To prevent sogginess, move quickly when you're building them and keep your heat steady at medium. Always start with toasted bread, it makes such a big difference.
What To Serve With Your Melts
We really enjoy these with some homemade crispy fries on the side. A fresh tangy coleslaw works great with all that richness. When it's chilly outside, try dipping these in some hot tomato soup. And don't forget to serve some crunchy dill pickles alongside, they really tie the whole meal together.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the deal with two different cheeses?
Cheddar brings sharpness while provolone adds creamy richness. They melt beautifully together!
- → Can I use a different kind of bread than rye?
You’re not stuck with rye—try sourdough, whole grain, or gluten-free slices if needed.
- → Why throw bacon into the sauce?
The smoky bacon flavor totally levels up the savoriness of the beef and cheese combo.
- → How do I stop the bread from overcooking?
Keep the heat on medium-low and monitor closely while grilling each side.
- → Can you prep the sauce in advance?
Absolutely—mix it up to 3 days earlier and stash it in the fridge to save time.