Pin it
Take a bite of these luxurious brownies that blend all the wonderful flavors of traditional banana pudding. These Banana Pudding Brownies mix the gooey goodness of brownies with smooth homemade vanilla pudding, sweet bananas, and crunchy vanilla wafers. Whenever I whip these up, my kitchen gets filled with vanilla and caramelized banana smells, taking me back to those sunny days at grandma's house enjoying her famous banana pudding.
I took these to our family meetup last week, and even my cousin's picky kids who hate fruit couldn't stop eating them. What's the trick? The bananas keep the brownies super moist while that pudding swirl adds the creamy touch that hooks everyone.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice
- Bananas - Go for ones with dark spots all over for maximum sweetness. I've noticed that bananas you think are too soft to eat work wonders in baking
- Vanilla Wafer Cookies - Make sure they're nice and crisp. Old cookies will mess up your dessert. I always grab two boxes since snacking while cooking happens every time
- Brown Sugar - Either light or dark works great, but dark gives more richness. Toss in a bread slice to keep it soft
- Butter - Stick with unsalted to manage saltiness yourself. Softened butter makes the smoothest pudding base
- Vanilla Extract - The real stuff makes a big difference in both the pudding and brownie layers
After tons of attempts, I've learned you need to measure your mashed bananas carefully - too much turns your brownies cakey, not enough and you'll miss that banana pudding magic.
Step-by-Step Baking Guide
- 1. Making Your Pudding
- First, get your vanilla pudding going - heat milk in a thick-bottomed pot on medium. Mix sugar, flour, and egg yolk in another bowl until light colored. Slowly pour the hot milk into this mix while whisking like crazy - I learned the hard way that going too fast gets you scrambled eggs instead of pudding. Put everything back in the pot and stir non-stop until it's thick enough to stick to your spoon, usually about 5-7 minutes.
- 2. Mixing Your Brownie Base
- While pudding cools down, start on the brownie mix. Melt butter just until liquid but not super hot. Stir in both sugars until completely mixed. Now comes the fun part - add those perfectly mushy bananas and watch the batter change completely. Add egg yolk and vanilla until everything looks shiny and well-combined.
- 3. Adding Dry Stuff
- Run flour, baking powder, and salt through a sifter - this quick step prevents lumps and spreads everything evenly. Gently fold this into your wet mixture, stopping as soon as you can't see flour anymore. Too much mixing ruins the fudgy texture we want.
- 4. Building Your Layers
- Now we'll create those awesome layers. Spread half the brownie mix in your pan - I use a spoon back to smooth it out evenly. Push a layer of wafers into this batter to create that classic banana pudding base.
- 5. Putting It All Together
- Drop spoonfuls of remaining brownie batter and cooled pudding in a checkerboard pattern. Pull a knife through to make swirls - I like making figure-eight shapes for the prettiest look.
Pin it
While testing this recipe, my kid suggested we sprinkle crushed wafers on top before baking for extra crunch. She was totally right - sometimes the best cooking ideas come from the most unexpected people.
Pin it
Mastering Oven Settings
Getting your oven temperature right matters a lot here. I keep a thermometer inside mine to make sure it's actually hitting 350°F. The middle should still wobble slightly when you take it out - it'll firm up as it cools down.
Getting That Perfect Consistency
The toothpick test works differently with these brownies because of the pudding parts. Look for damp crumbs from the brownie sections, while pudding areas will stay creamy.
Keeping Them Fresh
These treats actually taste better a day later after all the flavors mix together. Keep them in a sealed container at room temperature and they'll stay good for up to 3 days.
Pro Cooking Tricks
- Put parchment paper in your pan with extra hanging over the sides for easy lifting. Believe me, trying to scoop out that first brownie from an unlined pan is super frustrating
- Eggs mix better when they're not cold from the fridge. I put mine in warm water for 5 minutes if I forget to take them out ahead of time
- Don't overdo the swirling - too much mixing will blur your pretty pudding and brownie patterns
Pin it
Closing Thoughts
These Banana Pudding Brownies give you the best of both worlds - rich, gooey brownies plus the comfort of banana pudding. They've become my favorite thing to bring to gatherings, not just because they taste amazing, but because they make everyone happy with that first bite. I keep getting better at making them as I learn new tricks, but the simple magic of putting these two desserts together never stops wowing people.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why is flour measuring important?
- If you don’t measure it right, your brownies might turn dry. Scoop with a spoon and level it off, or just weigh it!
- → Can I swap with ready-made pudding?
- Homemade is best for richer flavor, but quick instant pudding works if you're short on time.
- → What kind of bananas work best?
- Bananas that are really ripe and spotty give the most flavor.
- → Are these okay to freeze?
- Totally! Just pack them in an airtight container and freeze for up to a month.
- → Why did my brownies turn out dry?
- Too much flour is the usual reason—make sure to measure accurately!