
Whip up this classic Southern dish - Buttery Mushroom Rice Bake. Folks nicknamed it 'church lady rice' since it appeared at every congregation meal. Combine beef broth, butter, mushrooms and rice for a taste that screams down-home cooking.
Benefits Of This Tasty Rice
Here's a comforting Southern dish that's super simple to prepare. Just crack open a few cans, toss in some butter, and your oven handles the rest. You can fix it beforehand and heat it up when needed. The edges turn crispy golden, and guests always beg for your secret.
Ingredients List
- Butter: A full stick, nothing beats the real thing
- White Rice: Go with long grain variety
- French Onion Soup: Grab one can
- Beef Consomme: Adds wonderful depth
- Mushrooms: Either canned or fresh will do
Cooking Instructions
- Begin With Fat:
- Drop your butter stick into a large baking dish - around 11 x 13 inches works great.
- Liquify It:
- Slide dish into a 350° oven. Wait until butter completely melts.
- Combine Ingredients:
- Remove dish carefully then dump in rice, soups, and mushrooms directly into your melted butter.
- Mix Well:
- Blend everything thoroughly so rice gets completely coated.
- Cook Thoroughly:
- Return to oven for roughly 35 minutes. Watch for a nice golden surface.
- Test Doneness:
- When finished, rice should feel tender and liquid mostly absorbed.
Potluck Champion
You'd spot this rice at every Southern church gathering. That's why everyone calls it 'church lady rice.' Folks always grabbed extra helpings, and someone would inevitably ask for the cook. It's the kind of food that triggers warm memories of family gatherings.
Simple Preparation
This doesn't call for any fancy kitchen tricks. Just throw canned ingredients with rice and butter, then let your oven take over. While it cooks, you can chat with your guests or handle other tasks. It comes out wonderful every single time.

Genuine Butter Matters
Skip the margarine and go for actual butter to make this dish stand out. It melts throughout and gives the rice an amazing flavor. Try to grab unsalted butter because the soup mixes already contain plenty of salt.
Prep In Advance
Got plans later? Cook this beforehand and warm it up when you need it. It reheats beautifully in the microwave or in your oven at a low temperature. Just what you want when life gets busy but you still crave homemade food.
Rice Selection Tips
Go for long grain options like Uncle Ben's for better results. If you choose fresh mushrooms over canned ones, sauté them in butter first. This step enhances their flavor when they mix with the other stuff.
Handy Advice
Don't open the oven door too often as it lets the heat out. At the end, test if the rice feels tender but not soggy. Pour in a bit of hot water if it seems too dry. After baking, let it rest for five minutes so everything settles nicely.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Fresh or canned mushrooms?
Fresh mushrooms win for taste. Chop them evenly and cook them slowly to release their liquids. Just brush them clean instead of rinsing. It's a bit more effort, but it’s worth it.
- → Can I switch the broth?
Absolutely! Beef broth works like magic, but chicken broth is a great swap. Just watch that salt! Clear and rich broths are what you’re aiming for.
- → How to keep it meat-free?
No meat? No problem. Veggie broth or even mushroom stock will do just fine. Make sure you season it well and maybe toss in some extra fresh herbs for more flavor.
- → Is this gluten-free?
Rice is naturally safe! The only thing to watch is your broth—make sure it’s certified gluten-free. And season it gently before adding anything else to keep it balanced.
- → What pairs well with it?
Serve it with a fresh green salad. Steamed vegetables or even some crusty French bread make for awesome sides that balance the richness.
- → Why isn’t the rice cooking?
Make sure the oven’s at the right temp. Add a little more broth or water, and keep the dish tightly covered. Let it bake a bit longer and check in multiple spots to be sure.
- → Bringing it somewhere?
Keep it warm by wrapping it up well. A thermos works in a pinch too! Maybe carry along extra broth if it needs reheating and pack it in deep containers.
- → Need a faster version?
Quick-cooking rice could save the day! Get all the ingredients prepped ahead of time, and use a properly preheated oven to speed things up. Still tasty, even with shortcuts.
- → Doubling the recipe?
Doubling’s easy! Just grab a bigger dish and allow for a little more cooking time. Keep an eye on the broth level and give it a mix halfway through baking.
- → Want a bolder taste?
Experiment with plenty of herbs! Fresh parsley, thyme, or garlic can boost the dish. Try mixing a couple of mushroom varieties, season each layer, and even splash in a bit of French wine.
- → Too soggy?
Next time, go for less broth. You can also leave the cover off for the last few minutes to dry it out. Make sure the rice is washed beforehand and the oven’s really hot.
- → How to make it creamier?
Try stirring in some soft cheese like cream cheese or mascarpone. A splash of cream or more butter before serving can step up the creaminess without going overboard.
Conclusion
Love this? Then you’ll enjoy creamy mushroom risotto too. Or, whip up some classic stuffed mushrooms for something different.