Pin it
This twist on a New England classic brings Southwest flair to traditional lobster rolls. Fresh lobster gets mixed with corn, avocado, and tangy lime for a tasty update that stays true to the original while offering something new and exciting.
I came up with these Southwest Lobster Rolls during a backyard party when I wanted to give my New England relatives a fun surprise. They were doubtful at first - I grew up in New England too, so I get it! But I knew great taste would win them over. These days, we can't have summer without making these when lobster's in season.
Ingredients
- Fresh lobster meat: About 2 pounds cooked gives you the tender, sweet foundation for these sandwiches
- Sweet corn: Gives a nice snap and natural sweetness that works perfectly with lobster
- Mayonnaise: Brings everything together with creaminess that doesn't overpower the other flavors
- Fresh lime juice: Adds a pop of freshness and cuts through the richness of both lobster and avocado
- Cayenne pepper: Delivers a subtle warmth you can adjust up or down based on your taste
- Fresh cilantro: Brings that unmistakable Southwest flavor profile to the mix
- Ripe avocado: Adds a smooth, velvety texture that makes everything more indulgent
- New England style hot dog rolls: Their flat sides are perfect for buttery grilling
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the lobster:
- Get all the meat out from the shells, making sure to grab every bit from the claws, knuckles and tail. Chop into small chunks about 1/2 inch big for the perfect bite-size pieces.
- Prepare the corn:
- Slice the kernels off the cob with a sharp knife. Put the cob straight up in a bowl to catch all the kernels and their sweet juice. Using leftover grilled corn? Even better - it'll add an amazing smoky taste.
- Make the dressing:
- Mix mayonnaise, lime juice and cayenne pepper until it's smooth. This creates a zesty base that will hold everything together while adding a little kick.
- Combine main ingredients:
- Carefully mix the lobster meat, corn and chopped cilantro into your dressing, covering everything evenly but being gentle with the lobster pieces.
- Add the avocado:
- Gently stir in diced avocado at the very end to keep it from getting mushy. You want distinct chunks that stay intact but get coated with dressing.
- Toast the rolls:
- Butter the flat sides of your New England hot dog rolls and cook them on medium heat till they're golden and crunchy, about 2 minutes per side. This step is key for getting that texture contrast with the filling.
- Fill and serve:
- While your rolls are still warm, load them up with the lobster mix. Eat right away to enjoy the perfect mix of warm, crispy roll and cool, creamy filling.
Pin it
The best thing about this dish is when the sweet corn pops against the tender lobster meat. I got the idea after seeing someone at a Maine seafood stand putting hot sauce on their regular lobster roll. That got me thinking about creating this Southwest version, which has become my go-to summer specialty.
Make-Ahead Tips
You can keep the lobster mix in the fridge for up to 24 hours if you leave out the avocado. Just put it in a sealed container with plastic wrap pushed right down on top to stop it from turning brown. When you're ready to eat, just mix in fresh avocado chunks and fill your toasted rolls. This makes hosting so much easier since you can do most of the work ahead of time.
Serving Suggestions
These Southwest Lobster Rolls go great with simple sides that add to the meal without stealing the show. Regular kettle chips give you that perfect salty crunch, and a light coleslaw adds a fresh contrast. For drinks, try a cold Mexican beer with lime or a citrusy white wine like Sauvignon Blanc. Putting out some extra lime wedges lets everyone add more zing if they want.
Pin it
Regional Adaptations
Some lobster purists might frown at changing the sacred New England lobster roll, but this Southwest take honors the original while playing with new flavors. We keep the classic butter-toasted split-top bun but take the filling in a whole new direction. If you're serving to traditional New Englanders, why not offer both the classic version and this Southwest one? You'll often find guests trying both and surprisingly falling for this unexpected twist.
Storage and Leftovers
Got filling left over? It turns into amazing next-day treats. Spread it on toasted baguette pieces for fancy appetizers or mix into scrambled eggs for a special breakfast. The mix will stay good in the fridge for about two days, though the avocado might darken a bit. Always toast your rolls fresh right before eating since they get soggy quickly once filled.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the easiest way to cook lobster for these rolls?
Boil or steam your lobster for 11-12 minutes, let it cool, and then remove the meat, cutting it into chunks bite-sized for easy eating.
- → Is frozen or pre-cooked lobster okay to use?
Sure, just thaw it completely and make sure it’s fresh. It’ll still taste great in these rolls!
- → What are some great sides to serve with these rolls?
Pair them with crunchy chips, creamy macaroni or potato salad, or crispy sweet potato fries for the ultimate combo.
- → How do I keep the avocado intact in the dish?
Add the diced avocados last, folding them gently so they’re coated without turning mushy.
- → Can I prep these rolls in advance?
You can make the filling earlier, but wait to toast the buns and assemble everything until right before serving for the best flavor and texture.
- → How can I make the rolls spicier?
Crank up the heat by adding more cayenne or tossing in some chopped jalapeños.