Tasty Grilled Cheese Buttered

This toasted cheese sandwich turns everyday items into a toasty, soul-warming favorite that offers crunchy, buttery bread and perfectly gooey cheese with every mouthful. Using just three common ingredients, you'll whip up a nostalgic snack that makes both youngsters and grown-ups happy.

I stumbled on this can't-miss approach back in my university days when I was cooking on the cheap, and it's stayed my favorite comfort meal for more than ten years now. Even my friends with chef training ask me to make this basic sandwich when they drop by on wet, gloomy afternoons.

Ingredients

• White bread: Go for good sandwich bread that's soft but sturdy enough to handle the butter and cooking heat
• Butter: Stick with actual butter left out to soften so it spreads easily and creates that signature rich taste that makes the outside perfectly golden
• Cheddar cheese: Grab American Cheddar for that traditional meltiness and familiar taste, though any cheese that melts well works great too

How To Make Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Gather ingredients:

Get all three items ready and let them sit at room temp for best results. The butter should be soft enough to spread without tearing the bread.

Prepare the skillet:

Warm up your nonstick pan over medium heat until you can feel the warmth when you hold your hand about an inch above it. Getting the right temperature helps brown the bread evenly without burning it.

Butter the bread:

Spread a thick layer of softened butter on one side of a bread slice, making sure to cover it completely right to the edges. This will help create that perfect golden crust.

Begin cooking:

Put the bread in the heated pan with the buttered side down and right away add a slice of cheese on top. The cheese should cover most of the bread for even melting.

Assemble the sandwich:

Butter one side of the second bread slice and place it on top of the cheese with the butter facing up. This gets the top slice ready for perfect browning when you flip it.

Cook and flip:

Let the sandwich cook until the bottom turns golden brown, around 2-3 minutes, then carefully turn the whole sandwich using a spatula. Keep cooking till the second side is also golden and the cheese has fully melted.

Repeat the process:

Do the same steps with the remaining bread, butter, and cheese to make the second sandwich.

Serve immediately:

For the tastiest experience, eat the sandwich right away while the outside is still crispy and the cheese is all melty and stretchy.

Pin it

Butter truly makes this sandwich special. My grandma always said to use real butter, never margarine, and sometimes she'd mix a bit of garlic powder into the butter for extra flavor. Those small touches turned a basic sandwich into something really memorable.

Perfect Cheese Selection

American Cheddar stands as the go-to pick for toasted cheese sandwiches because it melts so well and has that familiar taste we all grew up with. But trying different cheeses can make exciting new versions. Gruyère brings a nutty flavor that feels fancy, while mixing mozzarella and provolone gives you those amazing cheese pulls for photos. For something really special, try blending different cheeses like sharp cheddar with a bit of smooth brie or fontina.

Creative Add-ins

Though the simple three-ingredient version tastes great on its own, adding extra stuff can turn it into something totally new. Thin tomato slices add juicy freshness, while bacon gives you savory crunch. Sweet cooked onions bring depth, and thin apple slices paired with cheddar make a tasty sweet-salty combo. Just keep all add-ins thin so your sandwich cooks evenly and the cheese still melts right.

Pin it

Serving Suggestions

A toasted cheese sandwich goes perfectly with tomato soup for the ultimate comfort meal. The soup's tangy brightness balances out the rich, buttery sandwich. For something lighter, try it with a simple green salad with vinaigrette to cut through the richness. In summer, fresh fruit like grapes or apple pieces offer a cool contrast, while pickles give you that tangy bite that works well against the creamy cheese.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How can I make bread crispy?

Just spread soft butter all over each side of the bread, then let it sizzle in a hot nonstick pan for that golden crunch.

→ What's the best cheese to use?

Cheddar is ideal because it melts so smoothly and tastes great. For extra creaminess, give American cheese a try.

→ Can I try other types of bread?

Absolutely! Sourdough, whole-grain, or your favorite type of bread will give you unique flavors and textures.

→ How do I stop cheese from leaking out?

Use cheese slices that fit the bread perfectly and don’t overstuff to keep the cheese neatly in place.

→ What goes well with grilled cheese?

Pair it with tomato soup, a crisp salad, or even some tangy pickles for a comforting meal!