Pin it
This buttery garlic lobster tails approach turns what seems like a fancy restaurant dish into something you can easily whip up at home. The mix of juicy, soft lobster and flavorful garlic butter makes an impressive meal that's surprisingly easy to put together in your kitchen.
I first tried making these lobster tails when our anniversary dinner plans fell apart. Seeing my partner's reaction when I brought these gorgeous tails to the table was way better than anything we could've gotten going out.
What You'll Need
- Lobster tails: Try to grab cold water ones if possible since they're usually softer and tastier than the warm water kind
- Unsalted butter: Going unsalted lets you decide how much salt to add yourself
- Fresh garlic cloves: Chop them up yourself for way more punch than the stuff from jars
- Lemon juice: It cuts through the butter's richness and makes the lobster's sweetness pop
- Smoked paprika: Adds a light smoky touch that works really well with sweet lobster meat
- Fresh parsley: Gives a nice green color and fresh taste against the rich butter
- Lemon wedges: A quick squeeze right before eating makes everything taste brighter
Cooking Buttery Garlic Lobster Tails
- Set up the lobster:
- Turn your broiler on with the rack about 6 inches from the heat. Take kitchen shears and cut along the top shell of each tail lengthwise but stop before the fin. Slip your fingers between meat and shell to loosen it while keeping it attached at the end. Pull the meat up and rest it on the shell for that fancy restaurant look. Push the shell together underneath so it sits flat.
- Mix up your butter sauce:
- Melt your butter in a small pan over medium low heat until liquid. Take it off the heat, add your chopped garlic and let it sit for 30 seconds. Mix in fresh lemon juice, smoked paprika, salt and pepper until smooth. The warm butter will take the edge off the raw garlic but keep all that good smell.
- Get ready to cook:
- Put the opened-up lobster tails on a baking sheet lined with foil, leaving space between them. Brush them generously with about half the garlic butter, making sure it gets into all the nooks. Save the rest for later.
- Cook them just right:
- Put the lobster tails under the hot broiler for 4 minutes. Pull them out, brush on more garlic butter, then put them back for another 4-6 minutes. The meat should be white and reach 140°F inside. The shells will turn bright red when they're done.
- Get them on the table:
- Put the lobster tails on warm plates, brush with any leftover garlic butter and sprinkle with chopped parsley. Serve with lemon pieces for squeezing over just before eating.
Pin it
My favorite thing about this dish is when the garlic butter hits the hot lobster and that amazing smell fills up the kitchen. Everyone in my house knows dinner's ready when that scent drifts through the rooms and they all rush to the table.
Finding Good Lobster Tails
Getting great results starts with picking the right tails. Look for ones that look somewhat see-through when raw and stay away from any with weird colors or that smell like ammonia. Cold water tails from Maine or Canada usually taste best with a sweeter flavor and firmer texture than warm water options. They cost more but they're worth it for special dinners. If you're using frozen ones, let them thaw in the fridge overnight instead of rushing it for better texture.
Pin it
Great Side Dishes
These fancy lobster tails deserve good company on the plate. For a steakhouse feel, serve them with simple risotto or creamy mashed potatoes to soak up all that garlic butter. Roasted asparagus or a light green salad with lemon dressing gives a fresh balance to the rich lobster. Wine drinkers will enjoy a crisp Chardonnay without oak or a Sauvignon Blanc that works with the sweet lobster without taking over. For really special nights, start with a small cup of lobster soup to keep the seafood theme going.
Fixing Common Problems
If the lobster meat sticks when you're trying to lift it, sprinkle some cold water between the meat and shell to help it come loose. When cutting the tails, don't cut through the bottom shell if you want to keep that nice presentation. If they curl up too much while cooking, stick a wooden skewer through each tail lengthwise to keep them flat. Not sure if they're done? Lobster meat is fully cooked at 140°F when it's turned completely white with no clear parts left.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's the first step for broiling lobster tails?
Grab some kitchen scissors and snip along the top of the shell, stopping before the tail. Ease the meat from the shell and arrange it on top. Dry it off before it hits the oven.
- → How do I make perfect garlic butter?
Mix melted butter with crushed garlic, fresh lemon, smoked paprika, and season with salt and pepper. It's the secret to a bold, yummy coating.
- → When is lobster ready to eat?
Lobster meat turns opaque with a slight golden finish after roughly 8–10 minutes under the broiler. Don't let it overcook or it’ll lose its delicate texture.
- → Can I work with frozen lobster?
Absolutely! Just make sure it thaws completely in the fridge or in a cold-water bath to cook evenly.
- → What sides go best with this dish?
Think roasted veggies, silky mashed potatoes, or a fresh salad. Great combos for a full meal!