Pin it
I whipped up this simple chicken avocado sandwich one boring Sunday when I was tired of plain old lunch options. It's crazy how changing a few basic things can turn everyday ingredients into something so tasty. After plenty of testing (including one funny mess with super mushy avocados!), I've figured out just how to balance crunchy bread, tender chicken, smooth avocado, and melted cheese perfectly.
What Makes This Sandwich Special
This sandwich checks every box - crunchy exterior, creamy middle, and tons of flavor in each mouthful. What's really great? You can switch it up however you want, and you've probably got most stuff needed already in your kitchen. And it only takes a few minutes to make, so it's perfect when you're super busy but still want something yummy without cooking all day.
What You'll Need
- Main Components:
- 2 chunky sourdough bread slices
- 1 prepared chicken breast, cut thin
- 1 soft avocado
- 2 slices easy-melting cheese
- Butter or mayo for the outside
- Flavor Enhancers:
- Sea salt
- Freshly cracked pepper
- Any fresh herbs you like
- Tools:
- Big frying pan or flat grill
- Tough spatula
- Good knife
Easy Steps to Follow
- Getting Started
- Use softened butter and coat one side of both bread pieces completely. Turn them over and put cheese on both inner sides - this makes a moisture shield that keeps everything nice and crispy. Add a tiny bit of salt to the cheese.
- Adding Your Stuffing
- Put your hot sliced chicken on one bread piece, then arrange avocado slices nicely on top. Sprinkle with fresh pepper and a bit of salt. Put the other bread slice on top, keeping the buttered parts facing outward.
- Cooking It Just Right
- Drop your sandwich in a heated pan on medium. Let it cook about 3-4 minutes until it turns golden, then carefully flip it. Push down lightly with your spatula and cook another 3 minutes until the cheese gets all gooey and the bread turns perfectly crispy.
Tricks for the Best Results
Make sure your pan is actually hot before you put the sandwich in - if it's too cool, your bread will just soak up butter and get soggy. If you're using chicken from yesterday's dinner, warm it up a bit first so it won't cool down your cheese. Want extra crunch? Throw some grated parmesan on the buttered sides before cooking. And don't forget to let your sandwich sit for a minute before cutting - it really helps keep everything from falling apart.
Pin it
Ways to Switch It Up
I sometimes throw in crunchy bacon or thin prosciutto when I'm feeling fancy. Other times I'll add tangy pickled red onions, or kick up the heat with some jalapeño slices. Try swapping regular mayo for chipotle mayo or pesto to change the flavor completely. And feel free to play around with different cheeses - trying smoky gouda or spicy pepper jack can totally transform your sandwich!
Keeping It Fresh
These taste best right after cooking, but you can get everything ready ahead of time. Cook and slice your chicken and keep it wrapped up in the fridge. Just cut your avocado right before you make the sandwich though - nobody wants those brown spots! If you need to prep early, you can put everything together (except the avocado) and wrap it tight in foil, then keep in the fridge for up to 4 hours before you cook it.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do I stop sogginess?
Toast the bread first and only slice your avocado right before using. Save adding tomatoes until you’re ready to dig in.
- → How should I warm up leftovers?
Go for a toaster or regular oven to keep the bread crunchy. Steer clear of the microwave—it’ll ruin the texture.
- → What’s the deal with slicing chicken thin?
A quarter-inch is the sweet spot. Let it rest before cutting so all the juices stay locked inside.
- → What cheese melts best?
Provolone, cheddar, or Swiss all work amazingly. Choose what you love, but make sure it’s thin for an even melt.
- → Can I prep it early?
Pre-cook the chicken, but for the freshest results, assemble and grill the sandwich right before you’re ready to eat.
Conclusion
An easy and flavorful sandwich layered with juicy chicken, rich avocado, and perfectly melted cheese on crunchy toasted bread.