Pin it
This quick balsamic wild mushroom pasta turns basic items into a fancy-looking meal in just 15 minutes. The mushrooms get all sweet and sticky with balsamic vinegar, making a thick sauce that wraps around the tagliatelle ribbons for a super tasty dinner.
I came up with this dish on a cold, wet fall night when I wanted something warm but fancy. Now it's what I make when friends drop by without warning or when I need something quick but special after work.
What You'll Need
- Tagliatelle pasta works as your foundation with wide noodles that grab onto all the yummy sauce
- Wild mushrooms bring deep woodsy flavor try different kinds together for best taste
- Olive oil gets those mushrooms nice and brown
- Salt and pepper make the mushroom taste pop
- Dried thyme and sage add those woodsy plant hints that go great with mushrooms
- Smoked paprika brings a bit of campfire taste that makes everything better
- Chili flakes throw in some warmth you can add more or less
- Balsamic vinegar makes everything sticky and sweet-sour this makes the dish amazing
- Unsalted butter brings creaminess and helps make the sauce smooth
- Shallot gives a gentle sweetness nicer than regular onion
- Garlic cloves build that must-have flavor base
- Burrata adds a soft milky contrast to the earthy mushrooms
- Toasted pine nuts give you something crunchy and nutty
- Fresh thyme for sprinkling looks pretty and smells great
Tasty Balsamic Wild Mushroom Pasta Steps
- Get everything ready
- Wipe mushrooms clean with paper towel to get rid of dirt. Don't rinse them or they'll soak up water like crazy. Chop the shallot small and crush garlic cloves. Getting all this done first makes cooking way easier.
- Fix the pasta
- Get a big pot of water boiling hot and throw in plenty of salt. It should taste like ocean water. Drop in tagliatelle and cook until it's still a bit firm usually 7 to 9 minutes but check what the box says. Save half cup of the pasta water before you drain.
- Brown those mushrooms
- Get a big nonstick pan super hot with no oil at all. Toss in mushrooms and don't touch them for 2 minutes. Then stir and keep cooking another 4 to 6 minutes. This dry cooking trick forces water out of mushrooms so they taste way stronger.
- Add flavor and brown more
- Once mushrooms have shrunk and lost their water splash in olive oil and sprinkle with salt pepper paprika thyme sage and chili flakes. Mix well so all mushrooms get coated. Keep cooking until you see golden edges forming.
- Make it saucy
- When mushrooms look nicely brown pour balsamic vinegar over them. It'll make a loud sizzle in the hot pan. Let it bubble down a bit while stirring to coat everything. Drop in butter and stir until it's all melted making everything shiny.
- Throw in the flavor makers
- Turn heat down to medium and add chopped shallot and crushed garlic. Cook for just 1 to 2 minutes until you can smell them but they aren't brown. Garlic gets nasty when burnt so keep an eye on it here.
- Mix and dish up
- Dump drained pasta into the pan and toss around until every noodle gets covered in the balsamic mushroom mix. If it looks too dry add a splash of that pasta water you saved. Put on plates then top with torn chunks of burrata sprinkle pine nuts and drop fresh thyme leaves on top.
The wild mushrooms really shine in this pasta with their rich earthy taste that gets even better when they caramelize. My grandma showed me how to cook mushrooms in a dry pan which is what gives them that perfect meaty feel. Whenever I cook this dish I remember her standing at the stove waiting patiently for that golden color to show up.
Pin it
Prep Ahead Options
This pasta tastes best right after cooking but you can get stuff ready ahead of time. Clean and slice mushrooms up to two days before just keep them in a paper bag in the fridge. The finished dish stays good in a sealed container in the fridge for three days. When warming it up add a bit of water or broth and heat slowly. The flavors often get stronger overnight so leftovers can taste even better.
Swap These If Needed
Can't find wild mushrooms? Regular brown or white ones work great too. No tagliatelle around? Try fettuccine pappardelle or even linguine instead. You can use balsamic glaze instead of vinegar for something sweeter. If you don't do dairy just use more olive oil instead of butter and skip the burrata or try some non-dairy ricotta. Fresh herbs can jump in for dried ones just use 1 tablespoon fresh for every teaspoon dried.
What To Serve With It
Enjoy this pasta as your main dish with a simple arugula salad with lemon juice and olive oil drizzled on top. If you want something heartier add some garlic bread to mop up all that sauce. A glass of medium red wine like Pinot Noir or Sangiovese goes really well with the mushroom flavors. For special times put some seared scallops or grilled chicken on top to make it extra fancy.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which mushrooms should I use for this dish?
Wild types like porcini, shiitake, oyster, or chanterelle are ideal for rich flavors. Button or cremini mushrooms can work too if wild ones aren’t an option. For the best taste, mix different varieties.
- → What’s a good swap for burrata?
Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, or parmesan are excellent alternatives. Each brings a slightly unique touch but pairs just as perfectly with the mushroom sauce.
- → Can I switch the tagliatelle for another type of pasta?
Absolutely! Fettuccine, pappardelle, or linguine work beautifully. For chunkier pasta, go with rigatoni or penne. Anything sturdy enough to hold the sauce is a win.
- → How do I make this vegan-friendly?
Replace butter with olive oil or a vegan butter substitute, and skip the burrata. Instead, try vegan cream cheese or a cashew cream drizzle for that creamy finish. The mushrooms provide plenty of flavor on their own!
- → Can I get a head start on this meal?
Definitely. Slice and store mushrooms in the fridge up to 2 days ahead. You can also make the mushroom sauce early, then reheat when cooking the pasta. Add a little pasta water to refresh the texture as you reheat.
- → What wine pairs well with it?
An earthy red like Pinot Noir, Sangiovese, or Chianti is perfect with mushrooms. Fans of white wine will enjoy an unoaked Chardonnay or dry Vermentino with this pasta.