Pin it
This rich cowboy butter with roasted garlic takes everyday meals to incredible new heights. When garlic gets that nutty, mellow flavor from roasting and mixes with herbs and spices, you've got something that makes steaks, bread, and pretty much anything taste amazing.
I whipped up this cowboy butter for a family cookout once and it vanished even quicker than the main dishes. These days it's my go-to trick when I want to turn basic food into something that gets everyone begging for my secret.
Ingredients
- Garlic heads: Keep them whole for roasting until they turn sweet and soft
- Unsalted butter: Let it sit out till it's soft enough to stir easily
- Dijon mustard: Adds a nice zip without being too much
- Fresh herbs: Chives parsley and thyme to bring bright garden flavors
- Lemon juice: Cuts through the richness with a touch of sour
- Paprika cayenne and red pepper flakes: Making a gentle warmth that's not too spicy
- Kosher salt and pepper: The basics that make everything else pop
How To Make Roasted Garlic Cowboy Butter
- Prepare the garlic:
- First, turn your oven to 400°F. Just pull off the loose outer papery stuff from your garlic heads but don't break them apart. Slice about a quarter inch off the top so you can see the cloves inside. This helps them cook evenly and stay juicy.
- Create a foil packet:
- Put your trimmed garlic on some aluminum foil and pour olive oil all over them, making sure it gets down between the cloves. Wrap them up tight in the foil. This way they both steam and roast, which gives them that amazing sweet taste.
- Roast to perfection:
- Stick your foil package in the oven for 50 to 60 minutes. You'll know they're done when the cloves look golden and feel mushy when you poke them. Roasting changes that sharp garlic bite into something smooth and sweet.
- Extract the roasted cloves:
- Let them cool a bit, then squeeze each clove out of its skin into a bowl. They should pop right out if they're roasted enough. Make sure you get every last bit of that yummy roasted goodness.
- Combine butter and ingredients:
- Throw in your soft butter, fresh herbs, spices and everything else with the roasted garlic. Mix it all up really well so the flavors spread evenly. Your butter should look slightly golden with little bits of herbs showing throughout.
- Shape or melt as needed:
- If you want it as a spread, roll it in plastic wrap like a log and chill it. For dipping, just slowly melt it in the microwave and stir it now and then. You can use it either way depending on what you're making.
Pin it
The thing I love most about this butter is definitely the roasted garlic. I couldn't believe how different it tasted from raw garlic the first time I made it. It went from harsh to mellow in such an amazing way. Now my family bugs me to make this butter for every holiday dinner, and I always double the batch because it runs out so fast.
Storage Tips
This cowboy butter keeps really well if you store it right. For a few days, just pop it in a sealed container in your fridge where it'll stay tasty for about 5 days. If you want to keep it longer, wrap chunks in parchment paper and stick them in freezer bags. It'll stay good frozen for about 3 months. When you need some, you can either let it thaw in the fridge overnight or just cut thin slices straight from the frozen log to melt on hot food. Don't ever refreeze butter you've already thawed though - it'll mess up how it feels and might not be safe to eat.
Pin it
Serving Suggestions
This cowboy butter works on way more than just steak. Try melting some over grilled fish, especially shrimp or scallops where the buttery garlic taste goes perfectly with their natural sweetness. If you don't eat meat, it's awesome spread on corn or tossed with roasted veggies fresh from the oven. It makes killer garlic bread too - just smear it on a baguette and broil it quickly. Want to impress guests? Put some melted cowboy butter in a small dish surrounded by warm crusty bread pieces. Even plain baked potatoes become fancy restaurant sides with just a bit of this butter on top.
Customization Options
What's great about this recipe is how easy it is to change up. Want a taste of the Mediterranean? Swap the chives and thyme for sun dried tomatoes and basil. Like it hot? Double the cayenne and throw in some chopped jalapeño. For a citrusy kick, use lemon zest instead of regular salt and add some orange zest too. If you're into smoky flavors, try smoked paprika with a tiny bit of liquid smoke. Love herbs? Just double up on the fresh ones and add some rosemary. Vegetarians can put this on grilled portobello mushrooms, and if you can't do dairy, good plant-based butter works surprisingly well too.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the best way to roast garlic?
Cut across the top of whole garlic heads to expose the cloves, drizzle them with olive oil, and wrap in foil. Bake at 400°F until the garlic is soft and golden, about 50-60 minutes.
- → Which foods work well with cowboy butter?
Pair cowboy butter with grilled steaks, bread, shrimp, or roasted veggies for an easy flavor upgrade.
- → Can I prep this butter in advance?
Sure! Store your butter in a sealed container in the fridge, and it’ll stay good for up to 5 days.
- → How do you serve cowboy butter?
Shape it into a log for spreading, melt it down for dipping, or drizzle it over cooked food for a burst of flavor.
- → Can I tweak the spice level?
Of course! Add more or less cayenne, or skip it if you'd rather have less heat.