Pin it
These scratch-made Stuffed Egg Delights are a no-fuss starter that brings a mouthwatering appetizer to any get-together. With their velvety, zesty, and mildly seasoned profile, each mouthful features a buttery yolk center and classy look. For everything from holiday parties and morning gatherings to laid-back suppers, these stuffed eggs will surely win over your guests.
What Makes These Eggs Special
Stuffed eggs have stood the test of time as family favorites, loved for how easily they adapt to different tastes. The mix of silky egg centers, creamy mayo, zippy mustard, and a touch of sweet relish creates a taste that feels like home but keeps you coming back for more. Top them with a dash of smoky paprika, and you've got something that looks as good as it tastes, with that hint of smokiness taking this timeless starter up a notch.
What You'll Need
- Main Components:
- 12 big eggs, not cold from fridge
- 1/2 cup mayo
- 2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
- 2 tablespoons sweet pickle relish (if you want)
- Flavor Boosters:
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
- 1/8 teaspoon cayenne pepper
- 1/2 teaspoon smoky paprika for the top
- Extra Toppings If You Want:
- Snipped fresh chives
- Little dill sprigs
- More pickle relish
- Tools You'll Need:
- Big cooking pot with cover
- Cold water bath
- Decorating bag with fancy tip
- Blender or mixer
How To Make Them
- Getting The Eggs Just Right
- Put eggs in pot and add cold water until they're covered by an inch. Let water come to a boil, then take off heat, put the lid on, and wait 10-12 minutes. Drop eggs in ice water for 5 minutes.
- Getting Eggs Ready
- Take shells off under running water. Cut eggs down the middle. Scoop out yellow centers into a bowl and put the whites on your serving dish.
- Making The Stuffing
- Smash up the centers with a fork or blend until they're really fine. Mix in mayo, mustard, relish if using, and all your seasonings. Keep mixing until it's super smooth.
- Filling Your Eggs
- Spoon stuffing into your decorating bag with the fancy tip. Squeeze filling into each egg half making a pretty pattern.
- Final Touches
- Dust with paprika and add herbs on top. Let them chill for at least half an hour before you serve.
Tricks For Amazing Results
Grab eggs that aren't super fresh for easier peeling. Throw some vinegar in your cooking water so shells don't crack. Cool your eggs right away after cooking so you don't get that weird green ring. Let eggs warm up a bit before serving so they don't get wet. Make sure you really blend those yolks for the creamiest filling.
Pin it
Ways To Serve Them
Show them off on a fancy egg plate or over lettuce leaves. Try setting them in a circle with pretty garnishes in the middle. Serve them cool but not too cold for the best taste. They go great with raw veggies and other cold starters at a party table. You might want to make extra because they'll go fast.
Keeping Them Fresh
You can cook the eggs up to a week early and keep them unpeeled in your fridge. The filling can be made two days ahead and kept apart from the whites. Once you've put them together, they'll stay good for a day in a covered container. Always carry them flat so they don't slide around. Don't try freezing them because they'll turn mushy.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's the best way to peel eggs?
- Don’t use super fresh eggs. After boiling, dunk them in ice-cold water to keep the shell from sticking.
- → Can I prep these early?
- Yep, make them a day beforehand. Cover and chill in the fridge, but hold off on adding paprika until serving.
- → Why smooth out the yolks completely?
- Smash them really fine for a great smooth texture and nice, polished look.
- → How can I take these eggs to a party?
- Use an egg tray or flat container. Sprinkle paprika once you're set to serve.
- → Why pick smoked paprika?
- It has a nice smoky kick and adds color. Regular paprika works too but isn’t as bold.