Lobster Roll Pasta Salad

This pasta salad puts a new spin on the classic lobster roll, bringing together juicy chunks of sweet lobster with al dente pasta, all mixed in a light yet creamy sauce that feels like summer in a bowl. In my home, this clever combo has turned into my go-to dish whenever I'm hosting friends for a seaside-inspired get-together. I brought this to a beach party last week, and everyone—even the folks who swear by traditional lobster rolls—came back to grab more. What's my trick? I mix regular mayo with Greek yogurt to get that perfect rich-but-tangy flavor, while fresh herbs add brightness that works so well with the sweet lobster meat.

Key Ingredients and Shopping Advice

• Lobster: Go for fresh when you can, but good-quality frozen is totally fine
• Pasta: Cavatappi is best since its twists hold onto the sauce
• Celery: Don't throw away those leaves, they pack tons of flavor
• Chives: Pick fresh ones for that mild oniony kick
• Greek Yogurt: Fat-free works great and keeps things light
• Red Onion: Gives nice color and a bit of zing
• Celery Salt: This magic ingredient pulls everything together

Step-by-Step Guide

1. Get Everything Ready

Start by prepping all your stuff - get your lobster cooked and cut up, chop all your veggies, and get your water ready for the pasta. If you're using frozen lobster, let it thaw in your fridge overnight. Make sure to put plenty of salt in your pasta water - it should remind you of ocean water.

2. Cook The Pasta Right

Let your cavatappi cook just a bit past al dente - that extra cooking time makes cold pasta salad taste better. After cooking, drain it and run cold water over it right away to cool it down and stop it from sticking together.

3. Whip Up The Sauce

Mix light mayo with Greek yogurt in a bowl until they're completely blended. Sprinkle in celery salt and regular salt, tasting as you go. Make it a bit saltier than you think it needs - cold food needs stronger seasoning.

4. Mix It All Together

In a big bowl, put your lobster chunks, diced celery with the leaves, chopped red onion, and fresh chives. Pour your sauce over everything and fold it in gently. Add your cooled pasta and mix everything carefully so you don't break up the lobster pieces.

Pin it

Smart Cooking Tricks

• Save some herbs to sprinkle on top before serving
• Make a little extra dressing to freshen up leftovers
• Try to chop all veggies about the same size
• Use kitchen scissors to snip herbs easily
• Sample the salad after chilling to adjust flavors

Keeping It Fresh

You can keep this salad in the fridge for up to 2 days. Just store it in a container with a tight lid and add a bit more dressing and fresh herbs when you're ready to eat it again. For the best look and taste, set aside some lobster pieces to add right before you serve it.

Pin it

Pro Tips and Different Ways to Make It

After making this many times, I've found that adding some lemon zest really wakes up all the flavors. Sometimes I throw in diced avocado just before serving, or mix in some blanched asparagus tips for extra crunch and color. The main thing is keeping a good balance between the lobster and everything else.

Making It Look Fancy

For dinner parties, serve it in a wide, shallow bowl lined with butter lettuce. Top with extra chunks of lobster, fresh herbs, and lemon wedges on the side. You can even put individual portions in martini glasses if you want to really wow your guests.

Getting Temperatures Just Right

The secret to amazing pasta salad is watching your temperatures during prep. Make sure your pasta is completely cool before you mix everything together. Chill the finished salad for at least an hour so flavors can blend. Take it out of the fridge about 15 minutes before serving so the flavors can really shine.

Pin it

Wrapping Up

This lobster roll pasta salad gives you the best of both worlds - it's fancy enough for special occasions but practical enough for casual backyard parties.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What type of lobster works best?

You can use meat from steamed lobsters, tails, or high-quality pre-cooked lobster meat.

→ Can I make this in advance?

Absolutely! It can be made a few hours early and kept cool in the fridge.

→ What pasta can I use instead of cavatappi?

Rotini or farfalle are great replacements since they also catch the dressing well.

→ How can I make it healthier?

Switch the mayo entirely for Greek yogurt to lighten it up.

→ How long does it last?

Keep it chilled and eat within 2–3 days for the best taste.