Tasty Dill Potato Salad

This roasted potato salad with dill pickles turns simple spuds into a zesty, velvety treat that's ideal for backyard parties or as a filling side any time of year. The mix of crunchy roasted potatoes and the bold kick of dill pickles creates a taste combo that'll have everyone piling more onto their plates.

I whipped this up for a block party when I was tired of seeing the same old mayo-heavy potato salads. The dish was completely gone within moments, and now folks ask for it every time we fire up the grill in our backyard.

Ingredients

• Red potatoes: They're picked for their firm texture that doesn't fall apart after roasting, which works great in potato salad
• Dry ranch seasoning: Gives you a ready-made blend of herbs and spices without messing with tons of bottles
• Dill weed: Totally needed for that real pickle taste throughout your salad
• Bacon: Brings smoky flavor and crunchy bits; grab the thick-cut kind for best results
• Dill pickles: Go for the snappy, crunchy ones; stay away from sweet varieties as they'll throw off the flavor
• Pickle juice: This hidden hero makes your dressing tangy without making everything soggy
• Red onion: Adds bite and pretty color contrast; dunk in cold water for a few minutes if you want to take the edge off

How To Make Dill Pickle Roasted Potato Salad

Get potatoes ready:

Chop red potatoes into same-sized 1-inch chunks so they'll cook evenly while keeping their shape. Smaller pieces give you more crispy edges and soak up more flavor.

Add plenty of seasoning:

Mix potato chunks with olive oil, ranch mix and dill weed, making sure they're completely coated. The oil helps everything stick and makes the edges nice and crispy during cooking.

Roast them right:

Arrange potatoes in one layer with breathing room on your baking sheet. This lets air move around each piece for maximum crispiness. Don't forget to flip them halfway for golden crunch on multiple sides.

Cool with purpose:

Let those roasted potatoes cool at least 15 minutes before mixing everything together. This keeps your mayo from completely melting but lets the warm potatoes soak up some of those yummy dressing flavors.

Mix gently:

Fold everything together with a spatula instead of stirring hard. This keeps your potato chunks intact while making sure all the goodies are evenly spread throughout.

The secret weapon in this dish is definitely the pickle juice. My grandma always splashed a bit in her potato salad, but I've taken it up a notch by adding actual pickle chunks and extra juice in the dressing. It takes me back to summer gatherings at her farmhouse where this dish was always the first to vanish.

Pin it

Tasty Time-Saving Prep

This potato salad actually gets tastier when you make it ahead of time. You can fix it up to two days before you need it and keep it in a sealed container in your fridge. The flavors blend together wonderfully as it sits, with the potatoes soaking up more of that tangy dressing. If you're making it early, maybe save some of the bacon to sprinkle on just before serving so it stays crunchy.

Smart Swaps

Want a lighter version? Try using half Greek yogurt instead of all mayo. The yogurt's tang works great with the pickle flavor and cuts down on calories. Yukon Gold potatoes can step in for red ones if you prefer their natural buttery taste. Going veggie? Skip the bacon and toss in extra pickles or some roasted red peppers for color and a sweet contrast to the tangy dressing.

Pin it

Serving Suggestions

This potato salad goes great with anything off the grill, especially burgers and dogs. The tangy pickle flavor balances out fatty, rich foods perfectly. Try it next to pulled pork sandwiches for an awesome barbecue plate. For a fancier touch, serve individual portions topped with fresh dill sprigs and half a hard-boiled egg when you have dinner guests. The bold flavors also hold their own against spicy foods like buffalo chicken or blackened fish.

The History Behind The Dish

Old-school German potato salad often has vinegar and bacon, which likely shaped American versions that include pickles. This recipe updates those classic elements with handy ranch seasoning and roasting instead of boiling. Adding dill pickles shows the Eastern European influence on American food, where fermented and pickled stuff plays a big part in building flavor. This mix-and-match approach gives you the tastiest bits from several food traditions all in one dish.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I pick a different type of potato?

Sure! Yukon Gold or Russets work too, but red ones hold up when roasted and have a creamy bite.

→ Can I make this in advance?

Yep, prep ahead and refrigerate. Just keep the dressing off until you're ready to toss it together so it stays fresh.

→ Are there vegetarian swaps for the bacon?

Totally! Leave it out or go for plant-based bacon crumbles for a meat-free version.

→ Can I serve it warm if I want?

You bet! It’s tasty warm or cool—go with what you like best.

→ How long does it keep in the fridge?

Pop it in a sealed container and it stays good for about 3–4 days in the fridge. Keep it chilled!

→ Can I tweak how tangy the dressing is?

Of course! Add more or hold back on the dill pickle juice or mustard to match your taste.